Intermittent fasting has taken the health world by storm, with One Meal a Day (OMAD) representing its most extreme form. But here's where things get controversial: while advocates claim 23 transformative benefits that sound almost too good to be true, recent scientific research paints a more complex picture. Some studies suggest OMAD might actually elevate blood pressure and cholesterol levels—the very conditions it's supposed to improve.
So what's the truth? Let's dive into the most advanced form of intermittent fasting and explore both the remarkable benefits and the hidden risks that practitioners aren't always warned about.
What Is OMAD and How Does It Work?
OMAD (One Meal a Day) isn't technically a diet—it's an advanced intermittent fasting protocol where you compress all daily eating into a single 1-2 hour window, followed by 22-23 hours of fasting. Unlike gentler approaches like 16:8 fasting, OMAD triggers powerful metabolic changes by forcing your body to deplete glycogen stores and shift entirely to fat-burning mode.
The science behind it involves metabolic switching: your body transitions from using glucose as fuel to burning stored fat, creating a state called ketosis. This extended fasting period also triggers autophagy, a cellular cleaning process that recycles damaged proteins, viruses, fungi, and even candida.
The 23 Benefits: Too Good to Be True?
Financial and Time-Saving Benefits
Save Money and Time: When eating just one meal daily, you'll likely save at least $600 monthly on food costs. Beyond the financial benefits, you'll reclaim 1-2 hours daily previously spent on meal prep, cooking, and cleanup. This eliminates decision fatigue around food choices and reduces grocery shopping to one weekly trip.
Digestive and Immune System Improvements
Improved Digestion: OMAD gives your gallbladder, stomach, pancreas, and large bowel extended rest periods. This is particularly beneficial for those suffering from irritable bowel syndrome, allowing the digestive system time to heal.
Immune System Boost: The autophagy process strengthens immunity by recycling junk proteins and damaged cellular components. It also helps eliminate pathogens like viruses, fungus, and mold, providing a natural immune-strengthening effect.
Anti-Aging and Longevity Effects
Live Longer: Extended fasting periods have been linked to longevity benefits in multiple studies. The combination of reduced oxidative stress and enhanced cellular repair mechanisms contributes to this effect.
Better Skin: The autophagy process and anti-aging effects lead to smoother, younger-looking skin. Many practitioners report significant improvements in skin texture and appearance.
Metabolic and Energy Benefits
Increased Physical Energy: Contrary to what you might expect, OMAD practitioners report experiencing tons of physical energy once fully adapted to fat burning.
Mental Clarity and Euphoria: Many people experience improved concentration during fasted states, elimination of post-meal energy crashes, and even euphoric feelings. This mental clarity represents one of the most commonly reported benefits.
Improved Cognitive Function: OMAD has shown promise for improving memory, focus, and concentration. Research suggests benefits for dementia prevention and overall brain health.
Metabolic Flexibility: Your body transforms into a "fat-burning machine," making it easier to lose belly fat and achieve a flatter stomach. The extended fasting period fixes slow metabolisms by improving metabolic rate.
Hunger and Appetite Control
Reduced Hunger and Cravings: Once fully adapted to the keto state, hunger dramatically decreases. The body's transition to fat burning eliminates constant food cravings, making the protocol surprisingly easy to maintain.
Mood and Mental Health Benefits
Enhanced Mood: Depression and anxiety often stem from blood sugar instability. When this is addressed through OMAD, mood improvements are significant. Practitioners report feeling much better emotionally.
Cardiovascular and Blood Sugar Benefits
Heart Disease Prevention: Intermittent fasting may improve arterial health more effectively than almost any other intervention. The relationship between high insulin, insulin resistance, diabetes, and arterial problems makes fasting particularly beneficial for cardiovascular health.
Blood Pressure Reduction: Since high insulin causes elevated blood pressure, OMAD's insulin-lowering effects can naturally bring blood pressure down.
Diabetes Prevention and Management: OMAD helps prevent diabetes, improves pre-diabetes and insulin resistance, and can even fix hypoglycemia—a condition many people don't realize they have.
Inflammatory Conditions
Decreased Inflammation: Whether you suffer from bursitis, tendonitis, arthritis, or rheumatoid arthritis, the anti-inflammatory effects of extended fasting provide significant relief.
Liver Health
Fatty Liver Improvement: OMAD actively removes fat from the liver, helping reverse fatty liver disease.
Mental Discipline and Willpower
Strengthened Self-Discipline: The practice of withstanding food for 23 hours exercises and improves willpower and discipline. This mental training carries over into other life areas.
Muscle Preservation
Improved Muscle Physiology: Surprisingly, you won't lose muscle mass on OMAD. Growth hormone—the anti-aging hormone—increases during fasting and has a protective effect against muscle loss. This actually improves muscle density and mass when done correctly.
The Controversial Truth: What Research Actually Shows
Here's where things get uncomfortable for OMAD advocates. While the 23 benefits sound transformative, scientific research reveals a more nuanced reality that challenges some of these claims.
The Blood Pressure Paradox
One of OMAD's claimed benefits is blood pressure reduction through insulin lowering. However, a 2022 study published in Nutrients found that participants following one meal per day actually experienced elevated blood pressure compared to those eating three meals daily. This directly contradicts the promised benefit and raises serious questions about cardiovascular safety.
The Cholesterol Concern
The same research showed higher cholesterol levels in OMAD practitioners. While advocates claim heart disease prevention, these elevated cholesterol markers suggest potential cardiovascular risks that need careful monitoring.
Muscle Building Challenges
Despite claims of improved muscle physiology, building muscle on OMAD proves challenging in practice. While growth hormone does increase, the difficulty of consuming adequate protein (100-130g) in one meal and the lack of protein distribution throughout the day makes muscle growth significantly slower compared to traditional eating patterns.
The Dropout Rate Nobody Mentions
Studies on OMAD show high dropout rates, particularly for protocols lasting 8+ weeks. This suggests that while short-term adherence might be manageable, the extreme nature of OMAD makes long-term sustainability questionable for most people.
Nutritional Deficiency Risks
Healthcare professionals express concern about meeting all micronutrient needs in a single meal. While theoretically possible, in practice many OMAD followers struggle to consume sufficient vitamins, minerals, and fiber, potentially leading to deficiencies over time.
Women's Hormonal Concerns
OMAD can disrupt menstrual cycles and affect reproductive hormones in women. Those trying to conceive should avoid OMAD entirely, as extreme calorie restriction can impair fertility—a risk rarely mentioned in benefit lists.
Who Should (and Shouldn't) Try OMAD
OMAD May Work For You If:
- You've successfully maintained 20:4 fasting for several months
- Meal preparation time is extremely limited
- You prefer one large satisfying meal over multiple smaller ones
- You're using it as a short-term tool (2-12 weeks) for specific goals
- You're under medical supervision with regular monitoring
Choose Less Extreme Methods If:
- You're new to intermittent fasting
- Building muscle is your primary goal
- You have high athletic performance demands
- You're a woman with fertility concerns or menstrual irregularities
- You prefer gradual, sustainable approaches
- Social eating is important to your lifestyle
How to Start Safely: A Progressive Approach
If you decide to try OMAD despite the controversies, never jump directly from three meals to one. Follow this progression:
Weeks 1-2: Build Your Foundation
Start with 16:8 intermittent fasting—fast for 16 hours and eat within an 8-hour window. Focus on nutrient-dense whole foods and stay hydrated.
Weeks 3-4: Progress Gradually
Advance to 20:4 fasting with a 20-hour fast and 4-hour eating window. Consume two smaller meals within your window while monitoring energy levels.
Week 5+: Transition to OMAD
Only after mastering 20:4 should you attempt OMAD. Start with 2-3 OMAD days per week and gradually increase frequency as your body adapts.
Choose Your Eating Window Strategically
- Morning (7-9 AM): Best for those working in a fasted state
- Midday (12-2 PM): Ideal for social lunch schedules
- Evening (5-7 PM): Most popular for family dinners (research suggests earlier eating may provide metabolic advantages)
What to Drink During Your Fast
During your 22-23 hour fasting window, stick to zero-calorie beverages:
Allowed:
- Water (8-10 glasses daily)
- Black coffee (no cream or sweeteners)
- Plain tea (green, black, herbal)
- Sparkling water
- Zero-calorie electrolyte supplements
Not Allowed:
- Any beverage with calories
- Bulletproof coffee (butter and MCT oil break the fast)
- Protein shakes
- Juice or smoothies
- Diet sodas (may trigger insulin response)
Common Mistakes That Sabotage Results
- Starting too aggressively without building up through 16:8 and 20:4 first
- Eating poor quality food filled with processed items and empty calories
- Insufficient protein leading to actual muscle loss despite growth hormone protection
- Ignoring micronutrients by not including diverse, colorful whole foods
- Inadequate hydration during fasting hours
- Skipping electrolytes, especially sodium, potassium, and magnesium
- Not listening to your body when it signals persistent fatigue or mood changes
- Lack of planning resulting in nutrient-poor meal choices
A Typical OMAD Day
6:00 AM - Wake up, drink 16 oz water with pinch of sea salt
7:00 AM - Black coffee or green tea
12:00 PM - Herbal tea, light walk
3:00 PM - Electrolyte water, focus on work projects
6:00 PM - Start eating your OMAD meal (take 45-60 minutes)
7:00 PM - Finish eating, light cleanup
10:00 PM - Bedtime routine
Most people report feeling energized in the morning, with hunger peaking around traditional lunch time before stabilizing in the afternoon.
Summary
Intermittent fasting through OMAD offers compelling benefits: significant time and money savings, improved digestion, immune system strengthening, potential longevity benefits, enhanced mental clarity, reduced hunger and cravings, improved mood, and metabolic flexibility. The protocol can help with diabetes prevention, liver health, inflammation, and even mental discipline.
However, the controversy lies in what advocates don't always mention: research shows OMAD can elevate blood pressure and cholesterol levels, contrary to some claimed benefits. Building muscle proves challenging, dropout rates are high, and risks of nutritional deficiencies are real. Women face additional hormonal concerns that can affect fertility and menstrual health.
The truth? OMAD isn't for everyone, and it's certainly not the miraculous solution some make it out to be. For most people, less extreme fasting methods like 16:8 offer similar metabolic benefits with better long-term adherence, lower risk profiles, and more robust research support. If you do attempt OMAD, medical supervision and regular monitoring—including blood work and body composition scans—are essential to catch potential issues before they become serious problems.
The 23 benefits are real for some practitioners, but they come with asterisks, caveats, and risks that deserve honest discussion. Your health journey should be informed by both the promises and the realities.